Archives




View Full Version : Should we stimulate Detroit; or the New Market?


JusBringIt
02-23-2009, 05:43 PM
http://www.cleanmpg.com/photos/data/2/AmericanFlag.jpg In order to spur Innovation, Entrepreneurship needs to be endorsed. (http://techflash.com/Friedman_Stimulating_the_economy_through_venture_capital_40058962.html)

http://www.cleanmpg.com/photos/data/501/Detroit_Electric_-_Proton_Persona.jpgJohn Cook - TechFlash (http://techflash.com) - Feb 22, 2009

Should we invest in startups? For the record, the majority of entrepreneurs fail. -- Ed.

Columnist Thomas Friedman offers an interesting stimulus plan in today's New York Times.

Rather than sinking $20 billion in "the losers" of the U.S. auto industry, he suggests turning over $1 billion to each of the top 20 venture capital firms. Taxpayers would share in any financial upside achieved by the venture firms, essentially turning the American people into limited partners.

"As we invest taxpayer money, let’s do it with an eye to starting a new generation of biotech, info-tech, nanotech and clean-tech companies, with real innovators, real 21st-century jobs and potentially real profits for taxpayers," writes Friedman. "Our motto should be, “Start-ups, not bailouts: nurture the next Google, don’t nurse the old G.M.’s.”
We've heard similar proposals before, including Rob Coppedge's excellent guest column on TechFlash last month.

"A meltdown in the Innovation Economy will have longer-standing (and potentially much more severe) ramifications than the long overdue restructuring of the U.S. auto industry," wrote Coppedge, a Seattle venture capitalist in his plea to have some of the stimulus money go to the startup/venture community.

For those who believe that the U.S. economy is driven by innovation, the arguments of Friedman and Coppedge are easy to digest. But not everyone buys those arguments, one of the reasons why… http://www.techflash.com/Friedman_Stimulating_the_economy_through_venture_capital_40058962.html

chibougamoo
02-23-2009, 08:37 PM
Venture capitalists are sharks. They look at 1000 possibilities, find 10 that are viable but hemoraging, and offer a couple 10 cents on the dollar. Why would we support ANOTHER kind of pirate?

I'd like to see someone think about making a small EV platform with that money. I don't care whether it's bought from China or assembled using bankrupt-stock-robots and out-of-work autoworkers (whatever works best). Make that platform available to ALL the small EV companies, and they can finish the thing with their own stuff --- some might want just a rolling chasis; some might take it with a mini-style cabin, no interior; some might want to take it with an econo-box interior, and they just add the EV drivetrain.

Economy of scale. No one ever goes "broke" cause you just change out the guts from a model 1000 to a model 1010 from a different builder.

(Sigh) Things are always so much clearer after a bunch of Oreos and a cold milk

chilimac02
02-23-2009, 11:08 PM
Let's Take Chrysler's money and use it to start a government automobile company with the winner of the x-prize's design/business model. The 4billion dollar company could have a clause that stipulates it will become a private company in 4 years or whatever...

It can't be more risky than Chrysler...



Copyright 2006 Clean MPG, LLC. All Rights Reserved.