hobbit
11-12-2006, 09:56 AM
http://drdriving.org/ has a bunch of good articles on the various
psychologies behind road rage. The other day I started thinking
that maybe another big factor is simple frustration at not having
any good way to communicate with other drivers and have a reasoned
discussion about realtime traffic dynamics -- leaving everyone
with a few clumsy, ambiguous indicators which may or may not
be able to transmit intentions, opinions, or anything else about
what's going on. What does a car horn mean? It's like a baby
crying, you never know what it wants until you take the time to
check several possibilities. On the road there's no time to
do that. What if there were a reliable way to say "sorry, you just
made me feel very concerned for my safety by coming that close
and I'm sure most other people would agree, could you please try
to avoid doing that" to the guy who just cut you off? What would
his response be, especially if several other drivers around the
incident were able to also listen to the conversation and chime
in? If such a communication methodology did exist the babble
would probably be worse than the equivalent nest of cellphones,
but it would certainly make driver interactions very different.
.
My personal favorite would probably be "Look, if you always keep
your TRUCK that close behind other cars, buddy, you are one phone
call away from LOSING YOUR JOB -- do you have any idea how
dangerous that is?" ... which the Yuppie Button is sometimes
able to get across temporarily, but many of them are oblivious.
Or for the mpg-conscious, "Hey, I *am* going the same speed as
the traffic ahead, please stop asking me to close that gap
because I don't think it's safe and won't get either of us there
any faster" ...
.
While I can dream, such a facility would probably just turn into
a continual chorus of "F you, get the F out of my way" all day.
.
_H*
psychologies behind road rage. The other day I started thinking
that maybe another big factor is simple frustration at not having
any good way to communicate with other drivers and have a reasoned
discussion about realtime traffic dynamics -- leaving everyone
with a few clumsy, ambiguous indicators which may or may not
be able to transmit intentions, opinions, or anything else about
what's going on. What does a car horn mean? It's like a baby
crying, you never know what it wants until you take the time to
check several possibilities. On the road there's no time to
do that. What if there were a reliable way to say "sorry, you just
made me feel very concerned for my safety by coming that close
and I'm sure most other people would agree, could you please try
to avoid doing that" to the guy who just cut you off? What would
his response be, especially if several other drivers around the
incident were able to also listen to the conversation and chime
in? If such a communication methodology did exist the babble
would probably be worse than the equivalent nest of cellphones,
but it would certainly make driver interactions very different.
.
My personal favorite would probably be "Look, if you always keep
your TRUCK that close behind other cars, buddy, you are one phone
call away from LOSING YOUR JOB -- do you have any idea how
dangerous that is?" ... which the Yuppie Button is sometimes
able to get across temporarily, but many of them are oblivious.
Or for the mpg-conscious, "Hey, I *am* going the same speed as
the traffic ahead, please stop asking me to close that gap
because I don't think it's safe and won't get either of us there
any faster" ...
.
While I can dream, such a facility would probably just turn into
a continual chorus of "F you, get the F out of my way" all day.
.
_H*
